HDR Realism: An Exercise in Restraint
HDR photos rarely look “real”. Programs like Photomatix make it very easy to over-process your pictures to the point that they become abstract pieces of art. To create realistic HDR photos involves practice and skill. Ed Jesalva takes beautiful HDR photos with a focus on realism. He writes:
“I am an amateur photographer getting re-acquainted with photography in general, and digital in particular. I’ve really just been shooting landscapes this year but found a seminar at Brooks Institute to be particularly helpful in creating images like this one. HDR is a by-product of that. In my spare time, I’m a physician in Westlake Village, CA specializing in Psychiatry :)
My approach to HDR is to be as realistic as possible but use the tool as it is intended. That is, to compress the dynamic range so that there are details in both the shadows and highlight areas without giving the scene a “flat” look. In general, what I’ve noticed is sliders that increase contrast, decrease realism. Sliders that reduce contrast, increase realism.
I use (Adobe Photoshop) CS2 and Layer Masks almost exclusively. The general idea that I try to accomplish here is to generate a 3 dimensional effect. This means that elements in your scene have to have 3 tones in order to look 3D, highlights, midtones, and shadows. Trying to isolate each element to have these 3 components is my “secret” to creating photorealistic pictures, whether they are HDR or not.”
Finding the balance between realistic and over-processed is no easy task. What are your techniques for creating realistic HDR photos?



